Evaluating only PayAnywhere’s profile at its peak — without knowing the outcome — the model ranked Acquisition gone wrong as the #1 likely cause. Documented cause: Competition.
Key Events Timeline
FOUNDING
PayAnywhere launched by North American Bancard as mobile card reader for small business payments.
PRODUCT LAUNCH
Launched free POS software tier to compete with Square's free hardware promotions.
CEO CHANGE
Leadership realignment at North American Bancard deprioritized SME product investment.
SHUTDOWN
App updates ceased; 100,000 merchants migrated to hardware-focused replacement product with feature loss.
Full Analysis
Free · no account needed
Documented cause
PayAnywhere, a mobile point-of-sale and payments app owned by North American Bancard, was sunset as an independent SME product in 2022 after failing to grow beyond 100,000 active merchants. The product competed directly with Square and PayPal Here but could not match their ecosystem integrations or marketing budgets. North American Bancard internally redirected engineering resources to its enterprise product line in Q1 2022. PayAnywhere's iOS and Android apps stopped receiving updates in March 2022, and existing merchants were migrated to NAB's Payanywhere Smart products with significant feature regression.
Lesson
“Competing with Square requires ecosystem depth, not just hardware parity. Fee matching alone never wins.”