Evaluating only LithioVault’s profile at its peak — without knowing the outcome — the model ranked Unit economics as the #1 likely cause. Documented cause: Fraud.
Key Events Timeline
FOUNDING
LithioVault founded in Phoenix to develop hydromet lithium recovery from spent EV batteries.
FUNDING
Raised $31M Series A from Breakthrough Energy Ventures and DOE loan program commitments.
FRAUD EXPOSURE
Argonne National Lab published findings showing 61% actual recovery vs claimed 94%; DOE denied grants.
SHUTDOWN
Phoenix plant mothballed in January 2024; all assets auctioned in March 2024 after Series B collapsed.
Full Analysis
Free · no account needed
Documented cause
LithioVault raised $31M to build hydromet lithium recovery systems from spent EV batteries at a Phoenix, Arizona pilot plant. The company claimed 94% lithium recovery rates but independent testing by Argonne National Laboratory in Q2 2023 found actual recovery at 61%. DOE grant applications were denied after the discrepancy was published in October 2023. Anchor investor Breakthrough Energy Ventures declined to lead a Series B. The Phoenix plant was mothballed in January 2024 and assets were auctioned in March 2024.
Lesson
“Publish third-party validated recovery metrics before raising growth capital in battery recycling.”