Evaluating only Democracy Earth’s profile at its peak — without knowing the outcome — the model ranked Market collapse as the #1 likely cause. Documented cause: No market fit.
Key Events Timeline
FOUNDING
Santiago Siri and Virgile Deville founded Democracy Earth in Buenos Aires to build a blockchain liquid democracy protocol.
FUNDING
Accepted into Y Combinator S16 batch, raising $1.6M total to develop token-based voting infrastructure.
PRODUCT LAUNCH
Ran pilot vote with Colombian diaspora in Paris for 2016 peace referendum, gaining global academic attention.
SHUTDOWN
Project effectively ceased operations by 2021 with zero government contracts; Sybil attack concerns and regulatory uncertainty blocked all adoption.
Full Analysis
Free · no account needed
Documented cause
Democracy Earth, founded in Buenos Aires by Santiago Siri and Virgile Deville in 2015, raised $1.6M and received Y Combinator backing in 2016 to build a blockchain-based liquid democracy voting protocol. The project ran pilot votes with the Colombian diaspora in Paris for a 2016 peace referendum and gained significant academic attention. However, the open-source token-based governance model attracted minimal government adoption due to Sybil attack concerns and regulatory uncertainty. The non-profit structure made monetization near-impossible. The project effectively ceased operations by 2021 with no sustainable revenue.
Lesson
“Open-source civic protocols without a revenue model are experiments, not businesses; government adoption requires centralized accountability.”